Matthew Barbolini, a 24-year-old forward, was signed by the Toronto Maple Leafs as a U.S. college free agent following a four-year career at Miami University (Ohio). Standing at 6’2″ and 205 pounds, Barbolini fits the Leafs’ current strategy of building a bigger, heavier roster and deepening their pipeline of prospect talent. Barbolini suited up for 9 games with the Marlies at the end of the 2023-24 season, though he was scratched for their brief playoff run.
Strengths:
1. Offensive Production and Playmaking: Barbolini’s offensive abilities were a major asset during his college career. He consistently led Miami University in scoring, accumulating 85 points (36 goals, 49 assists) over 125 games. His knack for both scoring and creating opportunities for teammates made him a standout on the team. His frequent multi-point performances highlighted his vision and hockey IQ, allowing him to execute quick, intelligent plays in the offensive zone.
2. Defensive Responsibility and Two-Way Play: Barbolini is also highly responsible defensively. He excels as a two-way forward, contributing through forechecking, shot-blocking, and a willingness to engage in physical battles. His commitment to defensive play makes him an asset in both 5-on-5 situations and on the penalty kill. This dedication to both ends of the ice is a key part of his overall value as a player.
3. Physicality and Puck Protection: Barbolini leverages his size effectively, using his physicality to protect the puck and win board battles. He is tough to knock off the puck and excels in close-quarters play, often emerging with possession in contested areas. His strength also aids him in maintaining puck control while under pressure, helping him create scoring opportunities despite tight defensive coverage.
4. Leadership and Intangibles: Barbolini’s leadership qualities were evident during his time at Miami University. He was named team MVP for both the 2022-23 and 2023-24 seasons, underscoring his influence on and off the ice. His nomination for the Hobey Baker Award further highlights his work ethic and character, both of which will serve him well in his professional career.
Weaknesses:
1. Adaptation to the Pro Level: One of the main challenges Barbolini has faced is adapting to the professional level. In his debut with the Marlies, he struggled to find consistency, recording just 1 point in 9 games. This underscores the difficulty of transitioning from the NCAA to the faster-paced and more physical AHL. It is an area where Barbolini will need to improve to establish himself in the pros.
2. Skating and Speed: While Barbolini’s size and physicality are strengths, his skating — particularly his acceleration and straight-line speed — needs improvement. As the competition at the AHL and NHL levels intensifies, his ability to create separation from defenders will be crucial. Enhancing his explosiveness and foot speed will allow him to fully capitalize on his offensive instincts and maintain possession against stronger opponents.
Conclusion:
Barbolini has the potential to become a valuable two-way forward at the AHL level, with strong offensive skills, solid defensive awareness, and a physical presence. However, to make a significant impact in professional hockey, he must improve his skating and continue adjusting to the pace of the pro game. Signed for the next two seasons, Barbolini will have time to develop further, with the potential to utilize his size and strength to carve out a role as a big-bodied, bottom of the lineup, NHL forward.